Can Jodar's returning crack Shelton's serve at the Finals?
Shelton v Jodar Match page ›The better returner meets the steadier server
Jodar is the stronger returner of the two, and Shelton is the far more dependable server. On Thursday 19 November in the ATP Finals, one of those strengths has to give way.
Shelton has held serve in 88% of his recent service games, against 80% for Jodar. His serve rarely lets a game slip, so Jodar won't get many chances to break. Jodar, on the other hand, has broken serve in 29% of his recent return games, so he regularly takes games off players who are supposed to be winning them. Shelton's own figure is 18%. On return Jodar is well ahead, and it's the only department where he is.
Predictionist's own ratings, which are separate from the ATP ranking and built from results over the past year, also put Shelton ahead: No. 19 to Jodar's No. 29. The biggest factor in Predictionist's number is that rating gap together with how much more often Shelton holds serve.
Tiebreaks lean Shelton's way, long matches don't scare Jodar
If a set can't be separated, Shelton has the better record. He's 26–16 in tiebreaks this season, while Jodar is 9–11. Both samples are large enough to mean something: Shelton usually comes out on top of a tiebreak, and Jodar loses slightly more of them than he wins.
A long match doesn't look like bad news for Jodar, though. He's been strong whenever a match has gone to a deciding set this season, 18–7, so a third set is nothing he needs to fear. He also took the first set against Arthur Fils in his last match, so he can stay level with a good opponent for a while.
What the top-10 record does and doesn't say
Shelton has won six and lost five against the current top 10 this season, which is close to even. Jodar has won four and lost eight. One report this week called Shelton's record against top opponents alarming after his loss to Alexander Zverev, and that oversells it. A mark that's roughly even doesn't look like a crisis, and Jodar's is the weaker of the two.
The samples are small, 11 matches for Shelton and 12 for Jodar, so treat them as a hint and nothing firmer. Still, they don't back a story of Shelton struggling against the best.
A Zverev loss each, and no history between them
Both men have a loss to Zverev this week. Shelton beat Fils 6-2 3-6 6-3 on Sunday and then lost to Zverev 6-2 7-6(4) on Tuesday. Jodar lost to Zverev 6-4 6-4 and then to Fils 4-6 6-2 6-2 after winning the first set. Shelton has had the better week, with a win to go with his loss, while Jodar has lost both. But a few matches in a week is a small thing next to a whole season, so it shouldn't shift the picture much.
They haven't met before, so there's no pattern to lean on. That's the real uncertainty here. Nobody knows how Jodar's returning will look against Shelton's serve until it happens.
Our lean
We lean Shelton, and Predictionist gives him a 66% chance. Jodar's returning is good, but Shelton holds his serve so much more reliably that it tips the match his way. If Jodar keeps breaking him, though, this gets much closer.
What to watch
See whether Jodar gets a real chance to break Shelton in the first set. If Shelton moves through his service games untroubled, that fits the favourite's script. If Jodar earns chances early, that's the opening he needs.